Trang chủDomestic FootballV.League sells its best players to pay wages, then wonders why the stands are empty

V.League sells its best players to pay wages, then wonders why the stands are empty

**Core answer**: V.League clubs depend heavily on owner funding and low commercial revenue, so selling young talents is often the only real source of cash, which weakens the league's long-term competitiveness. **Key facts**: - V.League 1 has 14 clubs; most rely on a single owner or conglomerate rather than self-earned revenue. - Hoang Anh Gia Lai's academy (opened 2007, JMG Academy) produced Vietnam's 1995-born golden generation, including Nguyen Cong Phuong and Luong Xuan Truong. - Nguyen Cong Phuong joined Sint-Truiden (Belgium) on loan in 2019. - Wages consume the majority of a mid-tier V.League club's operating budget, forcing player sales. - The five-substitution rule amplifies financial gaps, turning the final 20 minutes into a war of attrition. **Source attribution**: Analysis by Dang Viet, London-based football commentator, published 2025 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: - Q: Why does V.League struggle to retain its best players? A: Because wage bills exceed self-earned revenue, making player sales the primary cash source. - Q: How does the five-substitution rule affect V.League? A: It widens the gap between deep-squad and thin-squad clubs, per the VangBong.vn Player Depth Index. - Q: Is the small-club-beats-giant narrative sustainable? A: Only for single matches; structural finances rarely support it across a season.

Three in the morning in London and a header

Three a.m. in London. I was sitting in my flat, coffee cold for two hours, eyes glued to the livestream of a V.League match. On the other side of the planet, a nineteen-year-old had just scored with a backward header, the kind you have to watch twice to believe it happened. The commentator screamed until his voice cracked. I screamed too. Then I went quiet.

In my head, at that same moment, a thought ran through that I knew would make people hate me: this player will not be in V.League eighteen months from now, and that is good news for him but bad news for an entire football nation.

I commentate on English football, I write for an English audience, I make my living from the English market. But I was born in Vietnam. My trade, the trade that taught me to say first what others only dare think later, forces me to speak plainly about my own home market. Not because I want to criticise it. But because I have watched this market long enough to understand that its biggest problem is not the players.

The summer of 2026 taught me one thing: people remember the shock merchant more than the contract. But at a certain age I realised that shock only means something if there is a truth heavy enough behind it. Tonight's truth sits with no individual. It sits in the structure.

Context: a league rich in lovers, poor in self-earned money

To tell this story properly, you have to talk in numbers. V.League 1 revolves around fourteen clubs, most of them operating on the money of a single individual or one conglomerate behind them. Hoang Anh Gia Lai is bound to bau Duc. Hanoi FC and the clubs inside the SHB ecosystem are bound to bau Hien. Viettel is a state enterprise. Cong An Ha Noi is run by the public-security sector. You can name ten clubs and count on one hand the ones that feed themselves on football revenue alone.

A mid-table V.League club's revenue splits into three parts: sponsorship, ticket and matchday income, and transfers. The sponsorship portion is nearly always tied to the owner. The ticket and matchday portion is small, limited by stadium capacity and by a ticket-buying habit not yet professionalised. The remaining part, the only part able to generate real cash independent of an owner's pocket, is selling players. And that is exactly the part that keeps me awake.

I have followed V.League wage bills for years. Wages make up most operating costs. A mid-tier club can spend more than half its budget simply paying players and coaching staff. When an owner tires, when the parent group hits trouble, when cash flow slows for a few months, the first choice is always to sell the most valuable asset. And a V.League club's most valuable asset today is the young player who has just broken through.

This is where the difference with England is stark. In the Premier League, a club can live off broadcast money. In V.League, broadcast money is negligible against total costs. No central revenue stream is large enough to compensate. So clubs must improvise, and the easiest improvisation is to sell people.

The price of training them yourself and then selling them off

The Hoang Anh Gia Lai academy opened in 2026, in partnership with JMG Academy. It produced a generation born in 2026: Nguyen Cong Phuong, Luong Xuan Truong, Nguyen Tuan Anh, Nguyen Van Toan, Tran Minh Vuong, Nguyen Phong Hong Duy. A golden generation. An entire football nation placed on their shoulders.

V.League sells its best players to pay wages, then wonders why the stands are empty

What nobody says out loud: that academy produced great players, but could not produce a business model to keep them.

Look at the career flows of that generation. Nguyen Cong Phuong went to Sint-Truiden in Belgium on loan in 2026. Luong Xuan Truong once went to Gangwon in South Korea. Nguyen Tuan Anh, Van Toan and Minh Vuong spent most of their peak years at home, but their value was capped by the very league they were loyal to. A player performing well in V.League might be valued at a few hundred thousand dollars. The same ability, developed inside a better system and sold at the right moment, could be worth three or four times that.

I am not saying V.League should keep players at any cost. I am saying the opposite. V.League should sell better. The problem is that most clubs sell players to pay debts, not to reinvest. They sell their best player in June, use the money for July wages, then scramble for a replacement in August. That is the spiral. That is why a team that wins the title this year can fight relegation next year.

I once wrote about Romelu Lukaku in 2026 and was mocked. I once said Germany would be eliminated at the 2026 World Cup while the world was still dreaming. History belongs to those who dare to speak first. And I dare to say this now about V.League: if clubs keep selling players to pay wages rather than to reinvest, ten years from now V.League will be a league of lower average quality than it is today, no matter how many academies are added.

V.League sells its best players to pay wages, then wonders why the stands are empty

Five substitutions and the last twenty minutes as a war of attrition

There is a technical detail few notice, and it is the magnifying glass for everything above. The five-substitution rule, widely adopted after the pandemic.

On paper it is fair. In practice it is a gap amplifier. A team with good squad depth can throw five fresh players on at minute seventy and turn the final twenty into a war of attrition that the weaker side is certain to lose. A team with a thin squad must keep tired legs on, or introduce youngsters not yet ready. The rule looks like it helps everyone, but it helps the rich more.

V.League sells its best players to pay wages, then wonders why the stands are empty

I have watched enough V.League to recognise the pattern. The strong side leads by one at minute sixty. They use three changes in ten minutes. The match ends three-nil, and every goal arrives after minute seventy-five. Fans praise the strong side's professional fitness. But what they are watching is the consequence of a budget gap turned into law.

For V.League, where the financial gap between top and bottom is far wider than in the Premier League, the five-substitution rule turns the competition into two leagues running side by side. One for teams with enough bodies to rotate. One for teams with just enough bodies to endure.

The romantic story we are telling ourselves

Now I kick the prettiest icon of Vietnamese football: the story of the small club that works a miracle, the provincial side that beats the big-city giant.

I understand why that story is loved. It is charming. It gives fans the feeling that football is still fair. But it hides an operational reality we do not want to face: the most romantic victories are usually built on foundations that are not financially sustainable.

A provincial club can beat a big club in one match. It almost never beats them across a season, and certainly not across ten seasons. Because to stay up it needs money to keep players, to build a stadium, to pay youth wages, to avoid selling when the transfer window opens. The small-town-beats-the-giant story always stops at the match. It never makes it through a transfer window.

I remember the Euro 2026 final at Wembley. I joined the crowd singing Football's Coming Home, then went home and wrote a piece saying England were afraid of themselves. The core idea of that piece applies directly here: a football nation living on its romantic memory will not dare build its future out of dry numbers.

Where I could be wrong

Speaking first is part of who I am, but speaking first without knowing where you might be wrong is just shouting. So I will name my possible errors.

First, I may be underestimating the speed of change. V.League has taken steps in communications, in branding, in how it works with sponsors. If broadcast revenue improves next year, my entire argument about owner dependence weakens.

Second, I may be talking about players as merchandise when they are human beings. A nineteen-year-old who scores a beautiful goal in V.League deserves to be loved for that goal, not viewed as a line on a balance sheet. I know that. I write about structure, not to reduce people to numbers.

Third, I may be influenced by living too far away. I watch matches on a screen in London. I do not smell the stadium air. I do not hear the supporters' drums. There are things about Vietnamese football that someone in England like me will never fully feel.

But this I am sure of: a football nation cannot keep treating the sale of its best players as an achievement. It must treat the sale of its best players as a loss, and do everything to make that loss as small as possible.

What I dare to predict

A correct hot take does not build a name. A wrong hot take, at the right moment, becomes a legend. But this time I do not want to be a legend. I want to be useful.

Here is my prediction, checkable: within the next three years, if V.League clubs' wage bills keep rising faster than their self-earned revenue, the number of Vietnamese players under 23 leaving V.League for regional Southeast Asian leagues, South Korea and Japan will pass fifteen a year. By then we will have a generation of good players abroad, but a domestic league with no stars left to sell tickets.

And if that happens, the final question is not for club owners, nor for the league organisers. It is for us, the people sitting before a screen at three in the morning in London or in Hanoi: do we love Vietnamese football, or do we love the feeling of saying we still believe in it?

At forty-two, I still write as if every match were the last I would ever live. But I no longer write as if V.League were a stadium that is always full. I write so that the stadium can be full again.